Madison, if you're okay with ebooks, you should check out Cassandra Curtis' I Put A Spell on You. It's out now by Amber Quill. Her books are fun and sexy!
Also, another good one is by Stobie Piel through Dorchester called Strange Brews.
I thought I heard my name being mentioned! LOL
Thanks, Cora.
I'm not sure if you're looking for dark paranormal romance witchy-stuff, witchy romantic comedy, or witchly fantasy, but you may want to check out Rosemary Edghill, especially her Bast series.